S&P Global Ratings maintained its stablecoin stability assessment for Tether’s USDT at a score of 5, the weakest level on its five-point scale, in a Nov. 18 review. The agency said assets it considers higher risk were equivalent to 28% of circulating USDT as of Sept. 30, up from 24% a year earlier. The assessment gauges a stablecoin’s ability to maintain its dollar peg and is not a formal credit rating.
Tether rejected the findings, telling Cointelegraph that the problem is S&P’s framework, not its reserves, and criticized the agency by referring to the 2008 financial crisis and the film The Big Short.
S&P highlighted changes in Tether’s reserve composition. Gold holdings rose from $12.9 billion in September 2025 to about $19 billion, while Bitcoin holdings declined from $9.9 billion to $8.4 billion. Tether also introduced $4.2 billion in public equity investments. The agency warned that a significant drop in the value of such assets could leave USDT undercollateralized.
BDO Italia’s latest attestation showed $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in liabilities, a collateralization ratio of 104.3%. Tether’s excess reserve buffer rose from $4.11 billion at end-June to $7.95 billion at end-September, with a quarterly net operating profit of $1.5 billion. Its direct and indirect U.S. Treasury bill exposure stood at $132.4 billion.
Despite Tether completing its first full independent audit with KPMG U.S., which issued an unqualified opinion and physically inspected gold bars, S&P noted that the financial statements and auditor’s report remain unavailable to the public. The agency also said quarterly reserve reports do not identify custodians, banking partners or counterparties, and disclosures on secured loans and corporate bonds remain insufficient.
S&P also questioned legal protections around USDT after Tether’s move to El Salvador. It considers El Salvador’s digital-asset oversight less stringent than U.S. and European frameworks because it permits exposure to assets such as Bitcoin, gold and loans without requiring reserve segregation. Tether maintains that its non-stablecoin operations are managed separately from USDT’s reserves.
Although the score remained weak, S&P acknowledged USDT’s history of maintaining its dollar peg. Direct redemptions are limited to verified customers holding at least $100,000, with a $150 verification charge and a redemption fee of $1,000 or 0.1%, whichever is higher. As of Oct. 25, Tron hosted 50.7% of circulating USDT, Ethereum 46.8%, and Solana 1.6%.