CLARITY Act Defeat: Trump's Ex-Crypto Chief Calls It 'Failure of American Leadership'

47 minute ago 2 sources neutral

Key takeaways:

  • CLARITY Act stall shifts crypto rulemaking to agencies, raising regulatory uncertainty for BTC and ETH.
  • BTC's 13.5% weekly drop signals traders pricing legislative delay, while ETH's resilience hints rotation.
  • Watch SEC and CFTC rulemaking; agency guidance may outweigh stalled legislation near-term.

The CLARITY Act, a comprehensive crypto market structure bill, has stalled in the Senate after a September 15 cloture vote failed 49-50, falling short of the 60 votes needed to begin debate. With Congress entering its final weeks and a new Congress convening in January, supporters face a critical decision on whether to resolve disputes over crypto oversight or let the bill expire and require reintroduction.

Patrick Witt, President Donald Trump's former top crypto adviser, called the defeat "a failure of American leadership" in an on-stage interview at Solana's Breakpoint conference in London. Witt, who served as executive director of the President's Council of Advisers for Digital Assets until last month, said he was "knee deep" in negotiating the bill for over a year. "We ultimately lost against the clock," he said, adding that "the policy was good. We resolved pretty much all of the policy differences." But with midterm elections approaching, "the political issue of ethics really consumed everything else."

Democrats had raised concerns over the Trump family's crypto ventures. Witt acknowledged that Trump's involvement in crypto was "arguably the issue," but noted the president had agreed to two ethics provisions. The second would have barred federal officials, including the president, from issuing or sponsoring digital assets, forced the president to divest certain digital assets or place them in a blind trust, and let state attorneys general enforce violations. "There's no precedent for those kinds of things in American law," he said.

The September 15 vote was not a final vote on the bill itself but a procedural step. Sen. Thom Tillis entered a motion to reconsider after the vote, preserving a procedural route but not guaranteeing a new attempt. Sen. Cynthia Lummis criticized Democrats' insistence on an SEC entrance for crypto businesses, while Sen. Elizabeth Warren tied her opposition to consumer protection and national security concerns.

With Democrats winning control of both chambers in the midterm elections, the negotiating dynamics will change significantly. The current Congress can still legislate during the lame-duck session, but any bill must compete for floor time with nominations and other business. A Senate Banking Committee hearing for prospective SEC commissioners Steven Levine and Kristin Johnson is scheduled for November 19 at 10 a.m. Eastern in Dirksen 538.

Looking ahead, Witt said the odds of passing a comprehensive replacement are low. "I would expect that market structure in the United States is going to be less written on Capitol Hill and more written in the Federal Register, which is where the agencies do their rulemakings and issue their guidance," he said. Parts of the Clarity Act could still pass in larger legislative packages, and lawmakers could grant targeted powers such as giving the Commodity Futures Trading Commission authority over spot crypto markets.

Despite the setback, Witt said he is "not bearish on the industry overall," noting that regulators and the president remain in place. He characterized opposition to crypto as increasingly generational rather than purely partisan, pointing to younger lawmakers like Sens. Angela Alsobrooks and Ruben Gallego who see crypto as "part of the fabric of financial infrastructure." Witt left the administration in October and said he has held talks with crypto firms, venture capital firms, and defense companies.

At the time of writing, Bitcoin traded at $64,618, down 0.3% in 24 hours and 13.5% over seven days. Ethereum was at $1,825, up 0.6% in 24 hours, according to CoinPaprika data timestamped November 16, 2026.

Disclaimer

The content on this website is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute investment advice, an offer, or professional consultation. Crypto assets are high-risk and volatile — you may lose all funds. Some materials may include summaries and links to third-party sources; we are not responsible for their content or accuracy. Any decisions you make are at your own risk. Coinalertnews recommends independently verifying information and consulting with a professional before making any financial decisions based on this content.